About a Studio: Muscle Shoals Sound Studio

In 1967, Aretha Franklin arrived at FAME Studios in Muscle Shoals, Alabama, to record her first session for Atlantic Records. She had been through several years of recordings for Columbia that had produced nothing that matched what she was capable of. Within the first session at Muscle Shoals she recorded I Never Loved a Man (The Way I Love You). It is one of the greatest vocal performances ever captured on tape.

The question of why that recording exists in that form is partly about Aretha Franklin, who was one of the finest singers of the twentieth century. But it is also about the room, the musicians, and the specific environment that Muscle Shoals had developed.

The town and what it offered

Muscle Shoals is a small city in northwestern Alabama, population around fourteen thousand, not a place that appears on the standard map of American music. And yet it produced a concentration of recording talent and a series of recordings through the 1960s and 1970s that have no parallel outside New York, Los Angeles, and Nashville.

The reason is partly Rick Hall, who founded FAME Studios in 1959 and developed a particular approach to rhythm and blues recording that combined the looseness and physicality of Southern music with the production values that were redefining pop and soul. Hall was not interested in replicating the sounds coming out of Motown or New York. He was interested in what happened when great musicians played together in a room and you put microphones in the right places.

The musicians Hall assembled became known as the Muscle Shoals Rhythm Section, or later the Swampers, when four of them left FAME to found Muscle Shoals Sound Studio in 1969. Barry Beckett, Roger Hawkins, David Hood, and Jimmy Johnson were not famous names outside the industry, but they played on so many records that their specific rhythmic sensibility became one of the defining sounds of American music in that decade.

What made the rhythm section special

The Muscle Shoals rhythm section had a quality that is easy to hear and difficult to describe. Their playing was loose in a way that felt controlled and tight in a way that felt relaxed. The groove they produced together was not metronomic. It breathed. It pushed slightly in certain places and pulled back in others in a way that created forward motion and physical weight simultaneously.

This quality is a product of musicians who had played together so extensively that their timing relationship was instinctive rather than learned. They were not following a click track and matching each other to it. They were following each other, and the result was a shared pulse that had character a mechanical tempo reference cannot produce.

Artists who came to Muscle Shoals from New York or Los Angeles, accustomed to studio sessions with highly professional but often interchangeable session musicians, responded to this immediately. Mick Jagger described hearing the playback of the first session at Muscle Shoals Sound and being stunned. The Rolling Stones had been making good records in London. What they got at Muscle Shoals was something different: the feeling that the musicians in the room were playing for the song rather than for the session.

The Rolling Stones sessions

The Rolling Stones recorded at Muscle Shoals Sound Studio in December 1969, in the immediate aftermath of the Altamont concert. Wild Horses, Brown Sugar, and You Gotta Move were all recorded in those sessions.

Wild Horses in particular carries the quality of the room. It is a slow, open recording where the relationship between the instruments is audible in the way they sit around the vocal. The production is not trying to add anything that was not already there. The song and the musicians doing justice to it: that is what the recording is.

Keith Richards has spoken about the Muscle Shoals sessions as among the most straightforward recording experiences of the band's career. The musicians knew what to do. The room was right. They played.

Aretha Franklin, Paul Simon, Bob Dylan

The range of artists who recorded at Muscle Shoals through the 1960s and 1970s reflects the reputation that the studios developed independently of genre. It was not a soul studio or a rock studio. It was a studio where musicians played well and recordings came out sounding like what they were supposed to sound like.

Aretha Franklin's Atlantic recordings, including Respect, which was recorded at FAME and then completed in New York, established the template. Paul Simon recorded There Goes Rhymin' Simon in Muscle Shoals, explicitly seeking the rhythm section he had heard on other records made there. Bob Dylan recorded Slow Train Coming at Muscle Shoals Sound in 1979, with Jerry Wexler producing.

The common thread is not genre. It is a desire for recordings that sounded like real musicians playing, with the specific quality that this particular group of musicians in this particular room could produce.

What happened and what it left behind

The classic era of Muscle Shoals recording, roughly 1967 to 1980, was tied to the specific personnel and the specific moment. As the original rhythm section members moved into producing and other work, as the music industry changed, as the economic model for expensive location recording shifted, the studios changed with them.

Muscle Shoals Sound Studio closed as a commercial recording facility, though the building has since been preserved as a music heritage site. FAME Studios is still operating.

What the Muscle Shoals recordings left behind is a body of work that demonstrates what happens when a group of musicians develops a genuine collective identity over years of playing together and then applies it to session work. The rhythm section brought something to every record they played on that was specifically theirs. It is audible on every recording. It could not be hired from a different city.

The lesson for recording is the same one that comes from every great studio story: the environment of a recording, the room, the musicians, the relationships between the people in the room, participates in what gets made.

There is a reason Wild Horses sounds the way it does, and that reason is partly Alabama in December 1969.

For more on legendary studios that shaped recording history, read about Puk Studios in Denmark and Sound City Studios or Mixing Consoles that shaped Recording Studios

Tapetown Studio / Tapetown Sessions

About a Studio: Hansa Studios, Berlin

Hansa Studios in Berlin is the studio by the Wall where David Bowie made "Heroes", Iggy Pop recorded Lust for Life, Depeche Mode made Some Great Reward and Black Celebration, and U2 started Achtung Baby. Its famous room, the Meistersaal at Köthener Strasse 38, is a 1913 concert hall a few hundred metres from where the Berlin Wall stood. This guide covers the building, the records made there, what the room did to them and what any band can take from Hansa into its own recordings.

Halfway through recording "Heroes", David Bowie steps back from the microphone. He had been singing close in, quiet and controlled. Then he moved back further, past the point where most engineers would call the microphone usable. Tony Visconti had set up three microphones at different distances, each gated so it only opened when Bowie sang loud enough to reach it. By the end of the song the furthest one was wide open and the whole hall was in the vocal. It sounds like someone performing for their life, and it could only have been recorded in that room.

Hansa Studios at a glance

• Address: Köthener Strasse 38, Berlin-Kreuzberg, close to Potsdamer Platz and the former Wall.

• The building: opened on 6 October 1913 by the Berlin building trades guild. The Meistersaal was a hall for chamber music and guild ceremonies.

• Hansa: founded by brothers Peter and Thomas Meisel. The Meisels bought the building in the mid-1970s and the Meistersaal became Hansa Studio 2, the "Hall by the Wall".

• Consoles: Hansa later bought three custom SSL 4000 E desks in its own "Hansa blue".

• Key records: Bowie's Low (finished there) and "Heroes", Iggy Pop's Lust for Life (and the mix of The Idiot), Depeche Mode's Some Great Reward and Black Celebration, U2's Achtung Baby (started there), Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds, R.E.M.'s Collapse into Now.

• Today: Hansa Studios still operates in the building. The Meistersaal itself has been an event venue since the 1990s and is still booked for concerts and recordings.

The building before Hansa

The Meistersaal opened in 1913 as part of a building for Berlin's construction trades guild. It hosted chamber music, readings and the ceremonies where master craftsmen got their certificates, which is where the name comes from. The building was heavily damaged in the Second World War and only patched up afterwards.

After 1961 it sat a stone's throw from the Berlin Wall, on the edge of a divided city. Record companies used the hall for sessions from the 1960s, and in the mid-1970s the Meisel brothers bought the building and set up the Hansa studios inside it. The official Meistersaal history and Hansa's own history page cover the dates.

Why did artists come? Berlin was cheap, it was politically charged, and it was cut off from the rest of the music business. The outside world felt far away. What happened in the room was the only thing that mattered.

David Bowie and the Berlin records

Bowie moved to Berlin in 1976 and made what became known as the Berlin Trilogy with Brian Eno and Tony Visconti. Only one of the three was made mostly at Hansa. Low was recorded largely at the Château d'Hérouville in France and finished at Hansa. "Heroes" was recorded at Hansa in 1977. Lodger was recorded at Mountain Studios in Montreux and mixed at the Record Plant in New York, so it is a Berlin-era album but not a Hansa album.

The "Heroes" sessions are inseparable from the Meistersaal. Visconti's gated distance mics on the vocal, Robert Fripp's guitar feedback played live in the room and the big, open drum sound all come from a decision to let the hall take part in the recording instead of controlling it out. The story behind the lyric fits the place too: Visconti and singer Antonia Maass were seen from the studio window, meeting by the Wall.

Iggy Pop: The Idiot and Lust for Life

Bowie produced both of Iggy Pop's 1977 albums. The Idiot was recorded at the Château d'Hérouville and Musicland in Munich, and Visconti mixed it at Hansa. Lust for Life was recorded at Hansa, fast, with the band playing together in the room.

You can hear it. The drums are physical and direct, recorded in a room that was not trying to separate the kit from everything else, and the bass and drums lock together the way they do when musicians react to the same air. It does not sound like a studio recording in the tidy sense. It sounds like a room. We have written about why that matters in recording a band live in a room.

Depeche Mode and the electronic era

In the 1980s Hansa became Depeche Mode's second home. They mixed Construction Time Again there in 1983 and recorded Some Great Reward (1984) and Black Celebration (1986), working with Daniel Miller and engineer and co-producer Gareth Jones. Those are the records where the band moved from synth-pop towards something darker.

A big reverberant hall sounds like the wrong place for synthesisers, which need no room at all. That was the point. Gareth Jones and the band played sounds back into the space and recorded the result, and the room added air, reflections and weight that a synth cannot produce on its own. The next record, Music for the Masses, was made elsewhere, mostly in Paris and London and mixed at Puk Studios in Denmark, which the band returned to again for Violator.

U2, Nick Cave and the post-Wall years

U2 began Achtung Baby at Hansa in late 1990, just after reunification, and finished it in Dublin. The sessions were famously difficult, and the band has said Berlin did not give them the magic they came for until "One" appeared. It is a useful lesson: a room's history is not something you can rent.

Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds recorded several albums at Hansa through the 1980s, and R.E.M. made Collapse into Now there in 2011. The list keeps growing, but the records from 1977 are still the ones that define what the studio means.

What made Hansa sound the way it did

• The room: a high-ceilinged 1913 concert hall with a long, musical decay. It flatters drums and vocals that are allowed to breathe.

• Distance miking: Visconti's gated mics on "Heroes" turned the hall into an instrument that responded to how hard Bowie sang.

• Playing together: Lust for Life and "Heroes" were tracked with musicians reacting to each other in the same space.

• Isolation of a different kind: not acoustic isolation, but the city's. No label people dropping in, no scene next door, nothing to do but work.

What Hansa teaches about recording rooms

You do not need a converted concert hall next to a Cold War border to make a great record. The lesson is that the room takes part in the music, in ways that are not fully controllable. Visconti did not know exactly what he would get when he pointed a mic at the far end of the hall and gated it to Bowie's volume. He had a theory, experience and good instincts, and then he responded to what happened.

Our opinion, which some engineers will argue with: most modern recordings are too afraid of the room. People treat every surface, close-mic everything and add fake space later. A real room with a real reflection is a decision, and decisions are what make records sound like somebody. We think about this at Tapetown every time we record a band live or on location in a difficult room. More on that in the room as an instrument and room and ambient mics for recording.

How to get some of the Hansa sound in your own recordings

• Put up a far room mic and actually use it. Gate or compress it so it only opens on the loud parts, the way Visconti did.

• Record the band together. Bleed between instruments is the glue on Lust for Life.

• Play sounds back into a space. Re-amp a synth or a drum machine through a speaker in a big room, like Depeche Mode did.

• Commit to the sound while tracking. The Hansa records were not rescued in the mix. Why that matters.

What an earlier version of this article got wrong

An earlier version of this post said Lodger was mainly recorded in Montreux and mixed at Hansa (it was mixed in New York), that The Idiot was made at Hansa (only the mix was), and that Music for the Masses was recorded there (it was not). It also repeated a claim about the building's wartime use that we could not verify, so we removed it.

Hansa Studios FAQ

What albums were recorded at Hansa Studios?

The best known are David Bowie's "Heroes", Iggy Pop's Lust for Life, Depeche Mode's Some Great Reward and Black Celebration, and parts of U2's Achtung Baby. Bowie's Low was finished there and Iggy Pop's The Idiot was mixed there. Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds and R.E.M. also recorded at Hansa.

Was "Heroes" recorded at Hansa Studios?

Yes. Bowie recorded "Heroes" at Hansa's Studio 2, the Meistersaal, in 1977, with Tony Visconti engineering and producing alongside Bowie and Brian Eno.

Why is Hansa called the Hall by the Wall?

Because the Meistersaal sat a few hundred metres from the Berlin Wall, near Potsdamer Platz. Bowie popularised the nickname in the late 1970s.

Is Hansa Studios still open?

Yes. Hansa Studios still operates in the building at Köthener Strasse 38. The Meistersaal hall became an event venue in the 1990s and is still used for concerts and recordings.

Can you visit Hansa Studios?

Guided tours of the Hansa building and the Meistersaal run regularly in Berlin. Check the Hansa and Meistersaal websites for current dates.

Keep reading

• Hansa Tonstudio and the magic of the Hall by the Wall

• Puk Studios, Denmark's hidden gem

• About a Studio: Sound City

• Inside Trident Studios

• Recording Hunky Dory at Trident Studios

• Vintage mixing consoles that shaped recording studios

Recorded your band in a room with character and want a mix that keeps it? We mix indie rock, post-punk and shoegaze for artists everywhere, and we have written about how we mix live recordings. Send us the rough mix.

Sweet Silence Studios: The Copenhagen Studio That Recorded Metallica and Michael Jackson

Before Metallica had a record deal, before they had a producer, before anyone outside the San Francisco Bay Area had seriously heard of them, they flew to Copenhagen.

This is not the obvious place for that story to go. But Sweet Silence Studios, operating out of a converted space in the Danish capital from 1977, had developed a reputation that was pulling in international acts long before the internet made that kind of discovery easy. They came for the room. They came for Flemming Rasmussen. And they left with some of the most important recordings in heavy music history.

How Sweet Silence started

Sweet Silence was founded in 1977 by Freddy Hansson. The studio was built with a seriousness of purpose that was unusual for Denmark at the time: a large live room capable of handling loud, amplified rock music at full volume, proper acoustic treatment, and a console and outboard equipment chain that could compete with anything in London or Hamburg.

Denmark in the late 1970s was not an obvious centre of gravity for international rock recording. That would change, and Sweet Silence was a significant reason why.

The studio's early work was primarily with Danish acts. But the combination of serious facilities, competitive rates relative to UK and US studios, and the calm working environment of Copenhagen, a city that unlike London or Los Angeles did not have a music industry culture that made every session feel like a transaction, began to attract attention from outside.

Flemming Rasmussen and the Metallica records

The name most associated with Sweet Silence's international legacy is Flemming Rasmussen, the Danish engineer and producer who worked there from the early 1980s. Rasmussen's relationship with Metallica produced three albums that define what heavy music can sound like when it is recorded with full conviction and serious engineering.

Ride the Lightning (1984), Master of Puppets (1986), and ...And Justice for All (1988) were all recorded at Sweet Silence. This was not an accident of geography. Metallica specifically sought out Rasmussen after hearing what he had done with other rock recordings at the studio. They returned twice because the combination of the room, the engineer, and the environment produced something they could not find at home.

Master of Puppets in particular is regularly cited as one of the best-recorded heavy metal albums ever made. The drum sound on that record, the way Lars Ulrich's kit sits in the mix with defined transients but genuine weight, is a product of the Sweet Silence live room and Rasmussen's understanding of how to capture a drum kit playing at maximum intensity. It is a specific, physical sound that belongs to that room and that engineer.

The irony is that Metallica were in some ways not a natural fit for the careful, attentive environment Sweet Silence provided. They were a loud, fast, abrasive band, and Copenhagen was a long way from their natural habitat. But the distance was part of the point. Away from the Bay Area scene, away from industry pressure, in a studio where the focus was entirely on the music, they made better records than they might have made in more comfortable circumstances.

The broader roster

Metallica were the studio's most famous international client, but the roster was wider than that.

Mercyful Fate, the Danish heavy metal band fronted by King Diamond, recorded several of their most important early works at Sweet Silence. The studio was part of the reason Denmark had an outsized influence on the development of European heavy metal in the early 1980s.

Michael Jackson recorded portions of work at the studio, a remarkable piece of evidence for how broadly Sweet Silence's reputation had spread by the mid-1980s.

A Perfect Circle recorded there.

Mew, one of the most significant Danish rock exports, used the studio. The list of artists who passed through represents a cross-section of serious rock and alternative music that few studios outside the major cities could match.

The common thread across the roster was a willingness to work with music that had real volume, real dynamic range, and real acoustic demands. Sweet Silence was built for that. Not every studio is.

What made it work

The standard explanation for Sweet Silence's success focuses on Flemming Rasmussen and his technical skill, which is accurate but incomplete. Rasmussen was exceptional, but exceptional engineers work well in good rooms and poorly in bad ones. The room was doing real work.

The Sweet Silence live room had the dimensions and treatment to handle loud acoustic sources without the problems that plague smaller or less carefully designed spaces. Low-frequency buildup, flutter echo, acoustic resonances: these were managed. The result was that what a band played in the room is what ended up on the recording, without the acoustic artefacts that a lesser space introduces.

The control room was calibrated to make accurate decisions. A control room that flatters certain frequencies, a common problem in studios that are built quickly or cheaply, causes engineers to compensate in ways that show up badly on playback elsewhere. Sweet Silence's control room let Rasmussen hear what was actually there.

And the studio offered the same thing that Puk offered in a different register: distance from the distractions and commercial pressures of London or Los Angeles, in an environment where making the record was the only thing happening.

The end of the original studio

The original Sweet Silence location closed as a commercial studio, a victim of the same structural changes that reshaped the studio industry from the mid-2000s onward. The combination of falling recording budgets, the rise of adequate home studio setups, and the end of the extended residential recording model that had justified large-format studios meant that the economic basis for a space like Sweet Silence became increasingly difficult to sustain.

The recordings the room produced are still there. The sound of Flemming Rasmussen's original space on Master of Puppets is still heard by millions of people. The contribution Sweet Silence made to Danish recording history, and to the history of recorded rock music more broadly, is permanent even if the physical space is not.

Denmark's recording legacy

Sweet Silence and Puk Studios, which operated in parallel and served different markets, together established Denmark as a serious international recording destination through the 1980s and 1990s. This was not a coincidence of geography. It was the result of people building serious facilities, developing genuine expertise, and attracting international attention through the quality of the work.

That tradition has not ended. It has moved. The studios are different. The music is different. The approach, building something serious, working with bands who mean it, caring more about the recording than about the industry, is the same.

Read about Puk Studios / Vintage Mixing Consoles that Shaped Recording Studios / How Tapetown Mixes Live Recordings

Tapetown Studio is a recording and mix studio in Aarhus, Denmark, working in the tradition of serious Danish recording. We record bands live and mix live sessions internationally.

tapetownstudio.com